PART FIVE — CELIA’S PERFECT RECORD
Celia had built her reputation on making other people explain themselves.
She had arrived in Alder Lane twelve years earlier with her husband, Warren Voss, who owned Voss Meridian Development.
Warren’s company renovated industrial sites, warehouses, municipal buildings, and aging commercial properties across southern Ohio.
He donated generously to school events and appeared in photographs beside local officials.
When he died of a heart attack four years earlier, Celia took over several charitable projects and became the neighborhood’s most visible volunteer.
She brought casseroles to grieving families and organized a holiday toy drive.
She also kept photocopies of homeowners’ signatures from voluntary committee forms and seemed to know details that residents had never told her.
For years, people had treated her curiosity as harmless gossip.
Daniel had begun questioning it after she mentioned a medical appointment he had never discussed publicly.
Now he wondered whether he had dismissed something more serious.
He was not prepared for what happened at the next community meeting.
Celia stood before thirty residents in the elementary school cafeteria, with a large photograph of Daniel’s house projected behind her.
She announced that the neighborhood had experienced a series of suspicious deliveries and that residents should report irregular packages immediately.
Then she turned toward Daniel, who had come only because Luis insisted he should see what she planned.
“Some homeowners,” she said, “have decided that private secrecy is more important than community safety.”
Daniel felt every head turn.
He asked her to remove his home from the presentation.
She said she had photographed it from a public sidewalk.
“That doesn’t make it relevant,” Daniel replied.
Celia folded her arms.
“Then tell everyone what federal investigators are doing at your house.”
A silence settled over the cafeteria.
Daniel had told no one about his meeting except Luis.
Celia smiled when she saw his reaction.
“You see how quickly trouble finds a neighborhood when people refuse to communicate?”
Daniel knew she wanted him to either reveal the investigation or lose his temper.
He did neither.
He asked whether she had proof of wrongdoing.
She said the question was inappropriate because her presentation was about safety.
Luis rose slowly from his chair.
“Then stop using a photograph of his front door as your safety lesson,” he said.
Several people murmured in agreement.
Celia switched off the projector and announced an early end to the meeting.
Outside, Daniel found his truck windshield covered with printed copies of the anonymous note that had been left beneath his wiper weeks earlier.
He picked up one copy with a tissue and photographed the others.
Luis watched from the curb.
“Someone wants you to look unstable in public,” he said.
Daniel wanted to chase Celia into the parking lot.
Instead, he called Bell and described what had happened.
Bell asked him to preserve the papers separately and photograph the position of each copy before touching it further.
Daniel could hear other voices in the inspector’s office.
After a pause, Bell asked a question that surprised him.
“Has Mrs. Voss ever asked to see your wife’s things?”
Daniel remembered an afternoon shortly after Maren’s funeral.
Celia had arrived with flowers and offered to help organize the donated school supplies in Maren’s home office.
He had refused because he was not ready to move anything.
She had asked twice more that month, calling the offer a practical kindness.
When Daniel told Bell, the inspector asked whether anyone had entered the office while Daniel was away.
Daniel thought about the neighbors who had brought meals, the relatives who had stayed overnight, and the cleaners he hired once after the funeral.
He could not account for every visitor.
Bell did not accuse any of them.
He simply told Daniel to keep the office secured and avoid searching it in ways that might disturb potential evidence.
That night, Daniel stood in Maren’s doorway looking at the shelves she had arranged by subject.
Her biology books occupied the bottom row, her student binders filled two cabinets, and a ceramic fox Nora had painted watched over the desk.
Daniel remembered Maren sitting there late at night, correcting papers while he made tea.
He remembered how she had insisted that the students record unsuccessful experiments as carefully as successful ones.
“An honest mistake teaches you something,” she used to say.
“A hidden mistake teaches everyone the wrong thing.”
Daniel could almost hear her voice as he looked at a framed school photograph on the wall.
He had spent two years protecting that room from change because he feared losing another part of her.
Now he realized that preserving it might have protected something else as well.
He took a photograph of the room and shut the door without moving a single object.
Across the street, Celia stood behind a window with her phone raised.
Daniel saw the tiny reflection of its screen before the curtain closed.